Why your time horizon matters
1 min read
Your time horizon is how many years you plan to stay. It changes the answer more than anything: over a few years renting almost always wins, and over many buying usually does.
The example
- Home:
- US$2,000,000
- Rent:
- US$12,000 a month
- Break-even year:
- 6
In year 1 renting is ahead; by year 10, buying is.
Year 1−US$92,121.52
Renting is ahead
Year 5−US$13,663.82
Renting is ahead
Year 10US$237,734.41
Buying is ahead
Year 20US$1,748,038.98
Buying is ahead
At first, buying carries the closing costs and a mortgage payment that's mostly interest. Over the years, the home gains value and the debt goes down.
If you don't know how long you'll stay, compare several horizons: the calculator shows the break-even year and the table shows every year.
Keep in mind we don't include selling: if you sell soon, selling costs make buying come out even worse.
Frequently asked questions
How many years is a few?
It depends on your case: if your break-even year is 6, staying less than that means renting wins.
What happens when the mortgage is paid off?
The buyer only pays maintenance from then on, so their lead grows faster.
Sources
- Month-by-month net worth calculation with different horizons.
Calculate yours
Compare my caseRelated guides
What we compare: net worth, not just payments
Why comparing what you build on each path tells you more than comparing rent with the mortgage payment.
Home appreciation and investment return
How home appreciation and the return on what you invest change the break-even year.
Did this help?