Why your time horizon matters

1 min read

Your time horizon is how many years you plan to stay. It changes the answer more than anything: over a few years renting almost always wins, and over many buying usually does.

The example

Home:
US$2,000,000
Rent:
US$12,000 a month
Break-even year:
6

In year 1 renting is ahead; by year 10, buying is.

  • Year 1−US$92,121.52

    Renting is ahead

  • Year 5−US$13,663.82

    Renting is ahead

  • Year 10US$237,734.41

    Buying is ahead

  • Year 20US$1,748,038.98

    Buying is ahead

Buying minus renting: below zero renting is ahead; over the years buying pulls ahead.

At first, buying carries the closing costs and a mortgage payment that's mostly interest. Over the years, the home gains value and the debt goes down.

If you don't know how long you'll stay, compare several horizons: the calculator shows the break-even year and the table shows every year.

Keep in mind we don't include selling: if you sell soon, selling costs make buying come out even worse.

Frequently asked questions

  • How many years is a few?

    It depends on your case: if your break-even year is 6, staying less than that means renting wins.

  • What happens when the mortgage is paid off?

    The buyer only pays maintenance from then on, so their lead grows faster.

Sources

  • Month-by-month net worth calculation with different horizons.

Calculate yours

Compare my case

Related guides

Did this help?

Next guide: Is renting throwing money away? What you don't get back either way