Home appreciation and investment return
1 min read
Two assumptions drive almost the whole result: how much the home goes up in value each year (appreciation) and how much the renter's investment earns.
The example
- Home:
- US$2,000,000
- Rent:
- US$12,000 a month
- Return:
- 7% a year
With 4% appreciation, buying wins from year 6.
2% appreciationbuying wins from year 16
4% appreciationbuying wins from year 6
6% appreciationbuying wins from year 2
With more appreciation, buying wins sooner. With a higher return on the investment, renting holds up for more years.
Neither is guaranteed: appreciation depends on the area, and the return depends on where you invest and how much risk you accept.
Try several values in More options to see a range of break-even years, instead of relying on just one.
Frequently asked questions
What appreciation should I use?
Recent appreciation for similar homes in your area is a good reference; use a cautious number.
What return should I use?
A cautious one for the way you'd invest; try several.
Sources
- Month-by-month calculation with different appreciation assumptions.
Calculate yours
Compare my caseRelated guides
What we compare: net worth, not just payments
Why comparing what you build on each path tells you more than comparing rent with the mortgage payment.
The costs beyond the mortgage payment
Closing costs, maintenance and property tax: what owning a home costs on top of the mortgage.
Did this help?