What we compare: net worth, not just payments
1 min read
Comparing rent with the mortgage payment isn't enough: what matters is how much you have at the end of each path. That's your net worth.
The example
- Home:
- US$2,000,000
- Rent:
- US$12,000 a month
- Mortgage payment:
- US$15,440.35 a month
At 10 years, buying leaves you US$1,792,099.60 and renting US$1,554,365.19.
Net worth if you buy, year 10US$1,792,099.60
Net worth if you rent, year 10US$1,554,365.19
If you buy, your net worth is what the home is worth minus what you still owe on the mortgage, plus what you invest in the months when owning costs less than rent (for example, once the mortgage is paid off). If you rent, it's what you build by investing the down payment and what you save each month compared with buying.
That's why the result tells you the year buying starts to leave you more than renting, not just which payment is lower.
For a fair comparison, the renter has to actually invest that difference. If it gets spent, renting comes out worse than the calculator shows.
Frequently asked questions
Why isn't comparing payments enough?
Because part of the mortgage payment becomes yours as home equity, and what you don't pay when renting can grow invested.
What if I don't invest the difference?
Then renting leaves you less than the comparison shows.
Sources
- Month-by-month calculation of net worth when buying and renting.
Calculate yours
Compare my caseRelated guides
Home appreciation and investment return
How home appreciation and the return on what you invest change the break-even year.
The costs beyond the mortgage payment
Closing costs, maintenance and property tax: what owning a home costs on top of the mortgage.
Did this help?