Is renting throwing money away? What you don't get back either way
1 min read
Rent doesn't come back, that's true. But buying also has money that doesn't come back, and at first it can be more.
The example
- Home:
- US$2,000,000
- Down payment:
- 20%
- Mortgage:
- 10% over 20 years
- Rent:
- US$12,000 a month
In the first year you pay US$158,808.34 in interest versus US$144,000 in rent.
Mortgage interest, first yearUS$158,808.34
Rent, first yearUS$144,000.00
What you don't get back if you rent
Each month's rent. In exchange, you don't pay closing costs or upkeep, and what would have been your down payment stays invested.
What you don't get back if you buy
Mortgage interest, maintenance and property tax, and closing costs. Also what your down payment would have earned if it had stayed invested.
What does come back
The part of the payment that lowers your debt and what the home gains in value. That's why the calculator compares net worth, not just payments.
In the first years
At first, the payment goes mostly to interest. In the example, the first year's interest is more than you'd pay in rent.
Frequently asked questions
So is buying better?
It depends on your numbers and how many years you stay. The calculator shows from which year buying leaves you more.
Does the down payment cost something too?
Yes: it's money that's no longer invested. What you stop earning on it counts too.
Sources
Calculate yours
Compare my caseRelated guides
What we compare: net worth, not just payments
Why comparing what you build on each path tells you more than comparing rent with the mortgage payment.
The costs beyond the mortgage payment
Closing costs, maintenance and property tax: what owning a home costs on top of the mortgage.
Why your time horizon matters
Why renting usually wins over a few years and buying over many.
Did this help?